Do I need life insurance when buying a home?

When Emily and Jake closed on their first home—a charming three-bedroom in a growing suburb—they were overwhelmed with excitement and paperwork. Their mortgage lender mentioned mortgage life insurance briefly, but between coordinating the move, setting up utilities, and furnishing their new space, it fell to the bottom of their priority list.

Three years later, during a financial planning session, their advisor asked about their life insurance. "Well, we have some through work," Jake replied hesitantly. The advisor did the math: Jake's work policy provided $50,000 of coverage—barely enough to cover final expenses and a year of Emily's income, let alone their $380,000 mortgage balance.

"If something happened to one of us," Emily realized, "the other would be stuck with the full mortgage payment on a single income. I don't think I could afford to keep the house."

This conversation opened their eyes to a critical gap in their financial planning—one that many new homebuyers overlook until it's too late.

The Financial Reality of Homeownership

Purchasing a home is typically the largest financial commitment most people make in their lifetime. When you sign that mortgage document, you're committing to payments that will span 15-30 years—payments that don't pause or reduce if your financial situation changes.

Consider the typical scenario: a couple with a combined income of $120,000 purchases a home with a $2,200 monthly mortgage payment (including property taxes and insurance). This payment is manageable on their dual income, consuming about 22% of their gross income.

But what happens if one partner passes away unexpectedly?

Suddenly, the surviving spouse faces that same $2,200 monthly payment on potentially half the income—now representing 44% of gross income instead of 22%. Add in the emotional devastation of losing a spouse, and the financial pressure can become completely overwhelming.

Marcus experienced this firsthand when his wife Lisa died unexpectedly at age 34. "We were both contributing to the mortgage," he explained. "When Lisa passed, I not only lost my partner, but I suddenly couldn't afford our home. I was facing a choice between moving my kids out of the only home they'd known or taking on a second job while grieving."

Fortunately, Lisa had insisted they purchase life insurance when they bought their home. Her $500,000 policy allowed Marcus to pay off the mortgage completely, eliminating the housing payment and giving their family the space to grieve without financial crisis.

Why Mortgage Life Insurance Isn't the Answer

Many mortgage lenders offer mortgage life insurance—a policy specifically designed to pay off your mortgage if you die. It sounds convenient, but it's typically not the best solution for most homebuyers.

Here's why mortgage life insurance has significant drawbacks:

Decreasing benefit, static premium: As you pay down your mortgage, the death benefit decreases to match your remaining balance, but your premium typically stays the same. You're paying the same amount for less coverage over time.

Lender is the beneficiary: The death benefit goes directly to your mortgage lender, not your family. Your spouse has no flexibility to use the funds for other purposes like income replacement, childcare, or relocating if they choose.

Limited flexibility: Mortgage life insurance only covers your mortgage. It doesn't address other financial needs your family might have, like replacing your income, paying off other debts, or funding children's education.

Less competitive pricing: Mortgage life insurance is often more expensive than comparable term life insurance because it's offered without medical underwriting in many cases—and that convenience is built into the premium.

When David and Rachel were buying their home, their lender strongly encouraged mortgage life insurance at $85 monthly. When they compared this to term life insurance independently, they found they could get $500,000 of coverage for $45 monthly—coverage that remained level throughout the term and paid directly to their chosen beneficiary with complete flexibility.

"We realized mortgage life insurance was convenient for the lender but not necessarily best for us," Rachel noted. They chose term life insurance instead, getting more coverage at half the cost.

How Much Life Insurance Do Homeowners Need?

The amount of life insurance you need as a homeowner depends on several factors beyond just your mortgage balance.

Mortgage balance: This is your baseline. At minimum, you want enough coverage to pay off the mortgage so your family can stay in the home without the burden of monthly payments. If your mortgage is $350,000, that's your starting point.

Income replacement: Beyond the mortgage, your family needs to replace the income you provided. Our detailed guide on how much life insurance you need to replace your income explains this calculation, but a general rule is 10-12 times your annual income.

Other debts: Car loans, credit card balances, student loans, and other obligations should be factored in. Learn more in our guide about using life insurance to cover debts.

Future obligations: College funding, childcare costs, and other long-term financial goals matter too. Paying off the mortgage is just one piece of comprehensive protection.

Final expenses: Funeral and burial costs typically range from $10,000-$15,000.

Let's look at a realistic example. Connor and Melissa have a $400,000 mortgage. Connor earns $85,000 annually while Melissa earns $75,000. They have two young children and $50,000 in student loan debt.

For Connor's coverage calculation:

• Mortgage balance: $400,000
• Income replacement (10x salary): $850,000
• Student loans and other debt: $50,000
• College fund contribution: $100,000
• Final expenses: $15,000
• Total recommended coverage: $1,415,000 (they round to $1.5 million)

For Melissa's calculation, they arrive at a similar amount: $1.3 million rounded to $1.5 million.

This might sound like a lot, but the monthly premium for a healthy 32-year-old might be just $65-$85 for $1.5 million of 25-year term coverage—less than many homeowners spend on streaming services.

Understanding how long your term should be helps you match coverage to your mortgage timeline.

When to Purchase Life Insurance for Your Home

The ideal time to purchase life insurance when buying a home is before you close—or immediately after. Here's why timing matters:

Before closing: Some buyers include life insurance as a condition of their financial planning before committing to a mortgage. This ensures you're fully protected from day one and helps you see if the mortgage payment remains affordable even if you need to dedicate some budget to insurance premiums.

Immediately after closing: If you didn't purchase beforehand, make life insurance your first priority once you've moved in. Don't wait months or years—every day without coverage is a day your family is exposed to financial risk.

Brittany and Tom's story illustrates why waiting is risky. When they purchased their home at ages 29 and 31, they told themselves they'd get life insurance "soon"—after they finished furnishing the house, after they settled into the new neighborhood, after things calmed down.

Two years later, Tom was diagnosed with a thyroid condition. When they finally applied for life insurance, Tom's condition resulted in a rated policy that cost 40% more than it would have if they'd applied when they first bought the house. "We waited because we were busy, and it cost us thousands of dollars over the life of the policy," Brittany said.

The lesson: don't wait for the "perfect" time. If you're healthy enough to qualify for a mortgage, you're likely healthy enough to qualify for excellent life insurance rates—but that won't remain true indefinitely.

Dual-Income Couples: Both Need Coverage

A common mistake is only insuring the higher-earning spouse. In dual-income households where both partners contribute to the mortgage, both need adequate coverage.

Even if one spouse earns significantly less, their income contribution still matters enormously. When Amanda's husband passed away, she had made sure he had substantial life insurance—but she hadn't purchased coverage for herself because she earned about 40% of what he did.

When Amanda unexpectedly passed away two years later, her husband faced a dilemma. Although her income had been smaller, it had been essential for their lifestyle and mortgage payment. Without it—and without life insurance to replace it—he struggled to maintain their home and ultimately had to sell.

"We thought we were being smart by prioritizing the bigger income," he reflected. "But the truth is, both incomes mattered, and both needed to be protected."

For dual-income homeowners, the guideline is simple: both partners should have life insurance coverage proportional to their financial contribution and the needs their income fulfills.

Renters vs. Homeowners: Different Needs

Some people wonder if renters need life insurance or if it's only necessary for homeowners. The truth is that life insurance needs depend on whether anyone relies on your income—not on whether you own or rent.

However, homeownership does create specific, substantial obligations that amplify life insurance needs. A renter's family can potentially move to less expensive housing if financial circumstances change, but a homeowner's family faces either making mortgage payments or selling the home during an already difficult time.

The mortgage obligation is also typically much larger than rent, and it can't be easily reduced. If you're paying $2,500 monthly for a mortgage, your family can't simply decide to pay $1,800 like they might be able to by moving to a smaller rental.

The Evoro Life Difference

At Evoro Life, we work with many first-time homebuyers who are navigating life insurance for the first time alongside their home purchase. We understand that buying a home is exciting but overwhelming, and we've designed our process to be as simple and quick as possible.

Our digital application takes as little as 18 minutes for qualified applicants, so you can secure coverage quickly without adding stress to your home-buying process. We specialize in working with young professionals who are generally healthy and lower-risk, which allows us to offer competitive rates.

We also provide clear guidance on coverage amounts that make sense for your specific situation—including your mortgage balance, income, and other financial obligations. Rather than pushing you toward the most expensive policy, we help you find the right amount of coverage to protect your family without overextending your budget.

Protecting the Dream of Homeownership

Buying a home represents stability, security, and the achievement of a major life goal. Ensuring that your family can keep that home—and the stability it represents—even if something happens to you is one of the most loving and responsible decisions you can make.

Life insurance transforms your mortgage from a potential burden into a manageable reality for your surviving family members. It means your spouse won't have to choose between grieving and scrambling to make payments. It means your children won't have to leave their home, school, and community during an already traumatic time.

The peace of mind that comes from knowing your family can stay in their home no matter what happens is worth far more than the modest monthly premium. Don't let this critical protection fall through the cracks during your home-buying journey.

Get your quote in 18 minutes